Jump to a section
A trade association announces a scholarship fund at its annual meeting. A sponsor pledges $25,000, members ask where to send their gifts, and staff put a donation button on the association’s website. The next morning the executive director sees that the announcement names the association, the sponsor’s letter names its charitable foundation, and the button deposits money in the association’s operating account.
The scholarship may be a good fit for the foundation. That still leaves three immediate questions. Which organization asked for the money? What did it tell donors? Which entity accepted the sponsor’s terms? The answers determine who can spend the funds, what records to keep, and whether the campaign can continue as advertised.
Which organization is running the program?
A public charity, a social welfare organization, and a trade association can all run educational programs. Their federal exemptions serve different purposes. A trade association may run training that improves conditions in its industry. A related charity offering scholarships must be able to explain how its selection criteria and use of funds serve its charitable purpose. Our article on choosing an exempt structure compares the three.
Before responding to the people who have offered money, check three records.
- The pledge letter. Which entity accepted the sponsor’s conditions, and what did it promise in return?
- The donation page and receipt. Who did the donor understand would receive the gift, and for what purpose?
- The deposit. Which entity received the funds and recorded the restriction?
If the answers point to different entities, preserve those records before deciding whether a transfer, donor clarification, or correction is appropriate.
What can we promise donors and sponsors?
A contribution restricted to scholarship awards raises a different question from unrestricted program support. If staff want to charge salaries, event costs, or a marketing campaign to the fund, check the grant letter, appeal, and gift terms first. A budget approved by the board does not release a donor restriction.
The sponsor may expect more than recognition on a website. Thanking it by name is different from promising an email that endorses its product and urges members to buy. The IRS distinguishes acknowledgment from advertising when determining whether a payment qualifies for the sponsorship exclusion from unrelated business income. Ask what the sponsor will actually receive before the benefits are promised or priced.
Can we start asking for contributions?
In Illinois, a charity generally must register with the Attorney General before soliciting, unless an exemption applies. An IRS determination letter answers a federal tax question. It does not establish that the state filing is complete. The Illinois Attorney General’s guidance and our article on registration explain the distinction.
If the association will send a national appeal for the foundation, identify who will solicit, who will receive the gifts, and where the appeal will go. That gives counsel something concrete to review before the announcement goes out. It also gives staff a clear answer when a member asks to whom the check should be payable.
Whose staff, money, and mailing list can we use?
Affiliated organizations often share an executive director, office space, and communications staff. Suppose the association’s staff spend several weeks administering the foundation’s scholarships. Who directed that work? Who paid for it? What do the organizations’ agreements say about reimbursement? The payroll, time records, and invoices should support the answer each entity gives its board, funders, and tax preparer.
Shared access to a mailing list raises another issue. Members who gave their details to a trade association may have received a particular privacy notice or opted out of fundraising messages. Before the foundation or a sponsor receives the list, check what members were told and what use the agreement allows.
What can we say about legislation or a candidate?
Assume a bill would expand funding for workforce education. The trade association wants members to call their legislators. Its foundation has been asked to host a candidate who supports the bill. Each organization needs its own answer.
A trade association recognized under section 501(c)(6) can generally lobby on issues germane to its purpose, although member-dues notices or a proxy tax may apply. A public charity can lobby within limits. Section 501(c)(3) prohibits participation in a campaign for or against a candidate. An invitation to speak can be permissible depending on the capacity in which the candidate appears, the audience, and how the event is run. Calling the event “educational” does not settle those facts. See the IRS guidance for business leagues and our article on candidate appearances and advocacy.
What should leadership see before the program continues?
For the scholarship campaign, useful records include the registration or exemption on which the organization relies, the sponsor’s agreed benefits, the terms shown to donors, and a reconciliation of gifts to awards and permitted expenses. If a donor raises a concern, the person who designed the campaign may have essential information. Someone with authority to act should decide who reviews the concern and whether notice is already due.
For a credentialing program, the evidence will look different. If accreditation depends on retaining exam incident records, ask the testing vendor to produce the records for a particular incident. An annual assurance that it follows the standard gives you less information than seeing what it can retrieve. Our article on the path of exam candidate data follows one record through a vendor’s systems.
If the dispute is over whether the executive director, a committee, or the board has authority to act, our Legal Guide to Association Governance addresses that question. For help reviewing a new program, a fundraising campaign, or a concern about the use of restricted funds, our Compliance Program Governance service can identify which entity needs to act and what it owes donors, members, or funders.