Article sections
The customer’s draft contract caps liability at twelve months of fees. That sounds familiar, so the provider accepts it and moves on to pricing. Months later, a claim comes in on the smallest of three projects. Is the limit based on what the customer paid for that project or everything it paid the provider?
Before agreeing to a cap, leadership needs to know how much the company could owe, which risks it can control, and what insurance would cover.
How the cap is calculated
Take a provider that has served a customer for two years and now has three statements of work (SOWs) in place. The customer paid $20,000 a month in total over the past twelve months. Each of the last two payments included $4,000 for the newest SOW, which runs for twelve months. A claim arises under that SOW just after the second payment.
- Fees paid under all SOWs in the 12 months before the claim
- $240,000
- Fees payable over the full term of the SOW giving rise to the claim
- $48,000
- Fees paid under that SOW in the 12 months before the claim
- $8,000
The largest limit is thirty times the smallest. A second claim raises another question. Does each claim have its own limit, or must all claims share one? Check how the agreement treats related incidents, separate orders, and claims by the customer’s affiliates.
Exceptions to the cap
Contracts often set a higher limit, sometimes called a super-cap, for confidentiality, data security, intellectual property, indemnity, or certain misconduct. Some exclude those claims from the cap altogether. A provider with administrator access to customer systems should pay particular attention to the data exception. A firm that builds products from third-party components should look closely at the intellectual property exception.
Which of the claims most likely to be expensive would also be uncapped?
Damages exclusions
A cap limits how much someone can recover. A damages exclusion rules out specified kinds of loss. Whether lost profits fall within an exclusion can depend on how the parties expected to earn money under the agreement.
In Biotronik A.G. v. Conor Medsystems Ireland, Ltd., 22 N.Y.3d 799 (2014), the New York Court of Appeals treated a distributor’s lost resale profits as direct damages under the parties’ distribution agreement. Depending on the wording, governing law, and commercial arrangement, a customer or provider may still recover lost profits under a contract that excludes consequential damages.
Indemnity
An indemnity can cover third-party claims, direct losses, or both, depending on its language and applicable law. Defense obligations, settlement authority, notice, cooperation, and exclusions matter as much as the amount. A broadly worded cap can reach indemnity obligations even if it never uses the word “indemnity.” Read the cap, its exceptions, and the indemnity together to see which limit applies.
Suppose a customer supplies a photograph and the provider puts it in a deliverable. If the photographer sues, does the provider have to defend the claim even though the customer chose the image? The answer depends on how the indemnity assigns responsibility for materials each party supplies.
Other remedies and response costs
If the customer receives a service credit, can it also demand a refund or sue for damages? Check whether credits, refunds, corrections, or replacement services count toward the cap and whether the customer can pursue more than one remedy.
Even if nobody sues, the provider may have to investigate an incident, restore service, and keep staff assigned to the customer. Include those costs when deciding whether the work is profitable at the proposed price.
Insurance
A certificate of insurance may show the limit the customer requested. To estimate what the insurer would pay for a particular claim, check the policy’s exclusions, deductibles or retentions, whether defense costs reduce the limit, and how much coverage other claims have used.
Ask counsel and the broker to compare the obligations in the customer’s draft with the policy. The provider may have to pay the difference itself.
Supporting documents and upstream contracts
A security exhibit or data processing agreement may promise reimbursement that the master services agreement (MSA) appears to limit. Read the exhibits, SOWs, and orders with the MSA, including the clause that says which document controls when terms conflict.
If a subcontractor causes an outage, the provider may owe its customer more than it can recover from the subcontractor. Compare those agreements before accepting the customer’s terms. The Provider’s Guide to Master Services Agreements explains how to read the MSA alongside the documents it governs.
Questions to answer before accepting a cap
Revenue, margin, access to customer systems, and the cost of failure all affect how much risk a provider can afford. Applicable law may also limit which terms a court will enforce.
Before signing, consider four questions.
- What limit does the cap produce for the most likely claim?
- Which obligations sit outside it, and how broadly are they worded?
- Which of the claims outside the cap would the policy cover?
- Do upstream vendor and subcontractor terms give the provider comparable protection?
Review your liability terms with us
If you are negotiating a services agreement or reviewing a customer’s draft, we can calculate the limits on likely claims, identify what your company would have to pay itself, and negotiate the terms with the customer.
Dan Liutikas is the founder and principal of Org Law, outside general counsel to executive teams and boards. He has more than 25 years of experience advising technology and service providers, franchisors, associations, and professional services firms on contracts, transactions, governance, and risk.